What the PIF Awards Actually Tell You About Who's Winning Independent Pet RetailPet Supplies Plus Ranked #1 in Pet Retail for Customer Service. The Award Itself Is the Shelf Tactic.Rhode Island Pet-Store Ban Includes Language That Could Choke Supply ChainsRedbarn Bets Functional Treats Can Win Shelf Space Treats Already Lost200 Free Gifts, Zero Shelf Strategy: What Barkwow's DTC Launch Says About the Personalized Pet Gift Category$1.4B Mars Spend Puts Independent Pet Retail in the SqueezePets at Home's Poppy Appeal Hit £1.6M Since 2018. The Charity-SKU Model Most Indies Can't Run.The Donation Box Fourteen Petland Stores Put Up in October Solves a Problem Most Retailers Don't SeeWhat the PIF Awards Actually Tell You About Who's Winning Independent Pet RetailPet Supplies Plus Ranked #1 in Pet Retail for Customer Service. The Award Itself Is the Shelf Tactic.Rhode Island Pet-Store Ban Includes Language That Could Choke Supply ChainsRedbarn Bets Functional Treats Can Win Shelf Space Treats Already Lost200 Free Gifts, Zero Shelf Strategy: What Barkwow's DTC Launch Says About the Personalized Pet Gift Category$1.4B Mars Spend Puts Independent Pet Retail in the SqueezePets at Home's Poppy Appeal Hit £1.6M Since 2018. The Charity-SKU Model Most Indies Can't Run.The Donation Box Fourteen Petland Stores Put Up in October Solves a Problem Most Retailers Don't See
On the ShelfBy The PetRetailNews Desk3 min readNovember 12, 2026
Pet Supplies Plus Ranked #1 in Pet Retail for Customer Service. The Award Itself Is the Shelf Tactic.
The chain landed #41 on Forbes' customer-service list. The real asset: a trust signal franchise owners can deploy before a customer asks a question.
The news: Pet Supplies Plus landed at #41 on Forbes' overall customer-service ranking and #51 on the Franchise Times Top 400 (its 23rd consecutive year on that list). Both rankings put it at the top of the pet retail category. The company operates more than 725 locally owned and corporate stores.
The asset the ranking actually delivers
Forbes' customer-service list evaluates personal interaction, speed, services, and resolution through a consumer survey. Franchise Times ranks franchise systems by global systemwide sales. For Pet Supplies Plus, the value isn't the methodology, it's the third-party validation a franchise owner can deploy as a trust signal before a customer ever asks a question.
That validation is doing work. It's pre-answering the doubt a shopper has when they're deciding between the neighborhood independent and the franchise location two miles away: which one will actually help me if this food doesn't work, or if I need to return something, or if I don't know what I'm looking for? The award gives the franchise store an answer that doesn't require the customer to trust the employee's claim, it outsources credibility to Forbes.
Chris Rowland, CEO at Pet Supplies Plus, said the rankings reflect "the dedication of our team members and franchise owners who make those moments count and help make our stores a meaningful part of the communities they serve." The company invests in team-member training on pet nutrition, wellness, and everyday care, and runs monthly adoption events and partnerships with local shelters.
Where independents actually compete
The independent store two miles away may stock better, may know the customer's dog by name, may have recommended the right joint supplement six months ago that the customer still talks about. None of that shows up on a Forbes list, and the customer walking in for the first time doesn't know it yet.
The franchise model gives Pet Supplies Plus something independents can't easily replicate: 725 locations executing a consistent service standard, all able to point to the same external ranking. An independent operates as a one-off. The experience might be better, but proving it requires the customer to try it first, and the award short-circuits that trial.
The counter-play isn't matching the chain's consistency or chasing a Forbes ranking. It's articulating the hyper-local service the chain can't replicate in a way that's as concrete as a third-party validation. That means specifics: the number of adoptions you've placed from your partner shelter in the last year. How long your trainer has been running the Saturday puppy class. Your return policy, stated plainly, with the thing you do that the chain doesn't.
The mistake is dismissing the award as corporate PR. The award is a tactic, and it's landing in 725 neighborhoods right now.
What changes Monday
If you run an independent and a Pet Supplies Plus franchise just opened within your draw, you're about to see this ranking deployed as a reason to switch. The response that works isn't "we care more", it's a sentence as concrete as the Forbes claim, something a customer can repeat to a friend. Write it down. Print it. Put it where the placard would go.
If you're a brand operator pitching independents, the service-ranking gap is now part of the retailer-selection conversation. Chains with rising service scores look like safer bets to a brand worried about execution at store level. If the independent can't prove they deliver comparable experience, not just comparable product knowledge, but the full service loop the survey measures, you're weighing risk every time you allocate inventory.
Pet Supplies Plus is actively seeking single- and multi-unit franchise owners. The company stocks over 11,000 products from 400 brands and offers curbside pickup, same-day delivery, and Autoship.
The award is a tactic, and it's landing in 725 neighborhoods right now.
The Forbes ranking evaluated consumer experiences across personal interaction, speed, services, and resolution. Pet Supplies Plus has appeared on the list for four consecutive years. The Franchise Times Top 400 ranks U.S.-based franchise systems by global systemwide sales; Pet Supplies Plus has been on it for 23 consecutive years.
Get the next issue in your inbox. Free, weekly, no fluff.