Sportsman's Pride is replacing its 40lb bags with 50lb formats across the sporting dog line

Sportsman's Pride is killing its 40lb bags. Sunshine Mills, which owns the brand, is moving the sporting dog lineup to 50lb formats, starting with the 26/18 Premium Complete & Balanced formula. The company said the decision came from repeated requests from dog owners buying for multiple dogs or purchasing in bulk.

The transition brings new packaging: bold imagery, clearer product callouts, and life-stage markers designed to help buyers find the right SKU faster. Alan Bostick, Sunshine Mills' CEO, said dog owners have been asking for bigger bags, and the company is giving them more of the nutrition they expect in the size they want.

The shelf reset stores carrying the brand face now

If you stock Sportsman's Pride, the 40lb SKU you've been reordering is going away. The 50lb bag takes its place, which means you're resetting shelf space, recalculating your per-unit buy cost, and deciding whether your sporting-dog customer base can support the larger format.

The per-pound economics may improve, since you're buying more product per transaction, but the trade is higher unit cost and more shelf footprint per SKU. If velocity doesn't support the jump, you're carrying more inventory that turns slower. Run the numbers on your current Sportsman's Pride movement before you commit to the new size. The 50lb bag is larger than the 40lb it replaces, so if your turn rate stays flat, you're tying up more cash per unit on the shelf.

Scott Merrill, Sunshine Mills' VP of Sales, said retailers have expressed interest in the larger format, recognizing the appeal among customers shopping for value and quantity. Whether that appeal holds in your specific customer base, or whether the 40lb size was already at the upper edge of what your regulars would buy, is what you need to know.

If your week runs on calls like this one, subscribe to PetRetailNews.

The packaging redesign and what it's competing against

The new bags feature prominent formula callouts, recognizable icons, and clearer life-stage identification. Sunshine Mills said the design is meant to create a strong, cohesive presence at retail and help consumers quickly find the right food.

The brand knows it's sitting next to newer performance lines with cleaner, more modern shelf graphics, and the old packaging wasn't holding its own. The redesign is Sportsman's Pride trying to compete visually with brands that have entered the sporting dog category with better shelf presence from day one.

Whether the new look moves product depends on how much of your sporting-dog sale is driven by brand loyalty versus shelf appeal. If your customer walks in asking for Sportsman's Pride by name, the packaging change is neutral. If they're browsing the performance aisle and comparing, the redesign might help, but it's still competing on the same shelf against brands with ingredient stories, sourcing claims, and price points Sportsman's Pride may not match.

Our read: the transition is a forcing function for stores already questioning the SKU

Sunshine Mills is counting on the customers who've been buying Sportsman's Pride in 40lb bags to step up to 50lb, and on the new packaging to pull in browsers who passed it over before. Both may be right, but the transition gives you a natural moment to re-evaluate whether this SKU still earns its shelf space.

If Sportsman's Pride has been a steady mover in your sporting dog section, the 50lb format probably works and the packaging refresh is a net positive. If it's been sitting longer than your other performance brands, this is the decision point: do you absorb the reset cost and the new unit economics, or do you use the SKU change as the reason to test a different line?

We'd watch whether other sporting dog brands follow Sunshine Mills into 50lb formats. If they do, the larger size becomes table stakes and you're resetting the whole section. If they don't, Sportsman's Pride is the outlier, and that either makes it the value leader or the SKU that doesn't fit the buying pattern your customers have.

What to do if you carry the brand

Pull your last six months of Sportsman's Pride movement. Calculate days-to-turn on the 40lb bag. If it's been moving at a pace that supports the larger format, the 50lb bag is probably safe. If it's sitting longer than your other performance brands, the 50lb bag adds risk: you're buying a bigger unit that may turn even slower, and your cash is tied up longer.

Talk to the rep about the transition timeline. Ask whether Sunshine Mills is offering any incentive to absorb the reset cost, and whether they're holding price per pound flat or adjusting it with the new format. If price per pound rises, the value story the company is pitching to consumers doesn't flow through to you, and you're deciding whether to hold your retail price and eat the margin or pass it along and test whether your customer will pay it.

If you've been considering dropping Sportsman's Pride or testing a different performance brand, this is the cleanest moment to do it. The SKU is changing anyway, so you're resetting the shelf regardless. The failure mode: you drop the brand, a loyal customer asks for it by name, and you've lost the sale. Know whether you have that customer before you make the call.

← Back to the Newsdesk