The profitable independent pet store that could justify a second location a few years ago is now facing a different equation: costs are rising, landlords are negotiating harder on lease terms, and the path to profitability has changed.
Retailers across the US and Europe are responding the same way, smaller formats, tighter assortments, and creative financing structures that weren't standard practice before.
The repeated move: new formats and new financing
Tractor Supply's new stores are generating return on invested capital between 23% and 25%, CEO Hal Lawton said in a recent conference, a level similar to what the company achieved 10 to 15 years ago. The rural lifestyle retailer's new locations are profitable in the first year and cash flow positive somewhere between year two and year three, Lawton said.
The company is expanding its use of sale-leaseback agreements: it constructs the building, sells it to a financial operator, and immediately leases it back. The arrangement lets the company recover invested capital while retaining use of the premises. According to Lawton, the company uses its balance sheet to fund the 18-month development cycle and pays the developer a flat fee, saving 10% on the cost of building stores.
James Cook, Director of Retail Research for Americas at JLL, a real estate services company, says the sale-leaseback model works mainly for large chains developing standalone properties. "That is a popular strategy with certain chains, but in the pet world, I can't think of anybody other than Tractor Supply that's really doing it," Cook said. Most large US chains, PetSmart, Pet Valu, Petco, and Pet Supplies Plus, rent spaces within shopping malls and existing locations because they seek places with high consumer traffic, Cook explained.
Meanwhile, retailers are adjusting store formats. Italy-based Zoopark looks for highly visible sites that are easy to access and offer convenient parking, founder and CEO Alexander Amicucci said. The company carefully evaluates the relationship between rental costs, local market potential, and expected revenue, Amicucci added. Because Zoopark invests its own resources in expansion, every new store must generate a return on investment within a reasonable timeframe. A new store generally reaches stable sales levels within approximately six months, depending on location quality, local brand awareness, and the team's ability to quickly build trust with customers, the CEO said.
Ukrainian pet store chain MasterZoo estimates new stores typically take around 12 months to reach mature sales levels, though this varies by market. Smaller-format stores require lower initial investment and typically achieve payback faster, COO Alina Kolesnikova said. The company evaluates size and profile of the local population, accessibility, foot traffic, availability of quality retail space, and the competitive landscape when selecting locations.
If you're planning your second location and the numbers don't add up the way they used to, subscribe to PetRetailNews.
What's driving the squeeze
The cost of everything involved with opening a store is rising, Cook said, citing energy prices, retail rents, cost of labor, construction materials, and goods. Commercial real estate services firm CBRE adds tariffs and labor shortages to the problem.
Data from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics shows the Producer Price Index for final construction rose 0.1% between May and June 2026 and 3.5% year-over-year. Compensation costs for civilian workers increased 0.9% in Q2 compared with Q1.
Retail real estate availability is also creating challenges. JLL's data shows US retail vacancy rates remain low, limiting options for companies looking for suitable locations. Availability in Q2 sat at 4.4%, Cook said. More recent data from Colliers puts the US retail vacancy rate at 4.3% in Q3 2026. The firm also reported that average asking rents reached $26.20 per square foot, up 0.7% quarter over quarter. Net absorption reached 10.5 million square feet, its highest quarterly total since 2023, highlighting continued demand for retail space.
CBRE's Q3 2026 data shows average asking rents reached $24.89 per square foot, up 2.5% year over year, while net absorption totaled 9.6 million square feet, its highest quarterly level since Q4 2025.
Lease negotiations are also becoming more complex, said Ken Bleznak, Executive Vice President at CBRE. Retailers are increasingly discussing who pays for construction costs, tenant improvement allowances, and other investments needed before opening a store. Tenants who previously did not request tenant improvement allowances, a pre-negotiated amount of money provided by the landlord to cover part of the construction costs needed to adapt the leased space, are now making it a deal point, Bleznak said.
Other rising trends Bleznak observed: higher return expectations from landlords, negotiations increasingly focus on restrictive covenants against competition, and co-tenancy clauses requiring a percentage of the project to be occupied.
Profitable expansion is no longer just about how many stores a retailer can open, but how effectively it manages the cost, format and location of each one.
What the pattern predicts
The shift toward smaller formats and creative financing isn't temporary cost management, it's a permanent recalibration of what a viable new store looks like.
Independents planning a second or third location face a choice: adjust the format and the SKU count to preserve margin density, or wait for construction economics that may not return. The financing structures most single-location operators can access are limited compared to what chains use.
For buyers, smaller formats mean tighter assortments and higher per-SKU volume thresholds. The categories that work in compressed space will hold shelf. The ones that need depth to convert will face pressure.
For brands pitching specialty distribution, the math has shifted. Retailers opening new stores with tighter assortments means less shelf space for emerging brands.
European retailers are already testing the formats that answer this pressure. Fressnapf | Maxi Zoo is expanding its urban store concept with locations designed for smaller city spaces. In Germany, ZooRoyal is growing both its standalone store network and its shop-in-shop presence within grocery and DIY retailers, allowing it to reach customers through existing retail infrastructure.
Bleznak says there's a shift toward more creative stores, designs, sizes, and formats, including shop-in-shop concepts such as Banfield Pet Hospital locations within PetSmart stores and Sephora outlets inside Kohl's department stores. Cook adds that both value retail and premium pet boutiques are among the winners in US expansion, supplying the K-shaped demand movement the economy has taken in recent years, with more consumers trading either up or down in purchases.
What would prove this wrong
Construction costs falling significantly, vacancy rates climbing meaningfully, or landlords competing for tenants hard enough to offer full tenant improvement allowances as standard. Any of those would reopen the traditional format playbook.
The other tell: if chains start opening more large-format stores in secondary markets rather than smaller ones, the format compression was a blip, not a shift.
The thing to watch next
How long it takes new stores to reach mature sales levels. MasterZoo's 12-month estimate and Zoopark's six-month window give a current baseline. If the ramp stretches longer, the financing structures that work today, landlord contributions, deferred rent, won't cover the gap, and expansion slows further.
The other signal: whether independents who opened smaller formats recently are opening second locations in the next year or two, or whether the first store stays the only store because the return didn't justify the risk.