The Spaw in Rapid City ran a loss-discount NFL promo and is outpacing last year's sales

The Spaw in Rapid City, South Dakota, is already outpacing last year's NFL apparel sales after launching pre-orders in the summer and running a promotion that discounts team merchandise 10% the week after a loss. The Dog Spot in Joseph, Oregon, sold 25 units of Territory dog toys at $14 each and reordered twice. Both stores shared the figures with Pets+ as their top sellers.

The football promo and what it bought

Shell Tomjack, who runs The Spaw, carries NFL jerseys and bandanas from Little Earth Productions for top regional and national teams, adding player-specific jerseys this year for Mahomes, Drake, and Kelce. The store began promoting the line in the summer and taking pre-orders, then set up a display inside the front door when the season started. The loss-discount promotion, 10% off team apparel the week after the team loses, drove repeat traffic. Tomjack said the store is outpacing last year's NFL sales, though the source does not give a percentage or dollar figure for the lift.

The tactic ties the discount to an external event the customer already cares about rather than an arbitrary sale date, which keeps the promotion from reading as desperation pricing. The customer comes back because their team lost, not because the store needed to move inventory, and that frame protects margin perception even as the discount runs.

The toy reorder and what it signals

Amy Wolf at The Dog Spot in Joseph, Oregon, sold 25 units of Territory dog toys at $14 each, led by the Cow 2-in-1 variant followed by the Pig, and reordered twice. The source does not specify the store's size, category mix, or whether the $14 price point sits above or below the store's typical toy range, so we can't say whether the velocity is unusual for this location or whether Territory is a new line the store is testing. Wolf said she may reorder again.

That reorder cadence suggests the store either underestimated demand or carries lean inventory by design. Either way, the velocity is real, and we'd watch whether it repeats in October or whether the back-to-routine period caught a spike that won't hold.

What the figures do not show

Neither retailer gave basket size, margin, or traffic data, so we can't calculate what the promotions or the toy sales cost in margin dollars or what else converted when the customer came in. The NFL promo could be driving $8 average baskets that barely cover the discount, or it could be pulling $60 baskets where the 10% off one item barely affects the total. The Territory toy could be cannibalizing sales of a higher-margin house brand, or it could be the entry SKU that leads to a $40 supplement add. The source does not say, so the figures are velocity markers, not profitability proof.

We also don't know whether other stores running similar promotions saw the same lift, or whether The Spaw's summer pre-order timing and front-door placement are doing the work the discount gets credit for. A promotion tied to team performance only works if the customer already planned to buy team merchandise. If they didn't, the discount is solving a problem the store doesn't have.

If you stock seasonal apparel or run event-based promotions, subscribe to PetRetailNews.

What a store of a given size should watch

For a single-location store: if you already stock NFL or college team apparel, the summer pre-order window Tomjack described is the move. It funds the inventory buy before the season starts and signals which teams actually have local demand. The loss-discount mechanic is worth testing if your customer base skews to one or two teams and you can track it without manual price overrides at the register. If you carry five teams and none of them dominate your zip code, the promotion becomes administration cost with no traffic payoff.

For a store testing a new toy line: Wolf's reorder cadence suggests she started with a small buy to test the SKU before committing to depth. That is correct if you are unsure whether a $14 toy will move in your market, but it also means you are out of stock during the weeks the product is proving it works. Most single-location stores should start lean, but have the reorder queued before the first unit sells so the lead time does not cost you the second week of velocity.

← Back to the Newsdesk