Here's what just happened
Pets+ just named nine independent pet businesses as 2025 America's Coolest Store winners, sponsored by SuperZoo. The list spans Vermont to New Jersey to Missouri, and includes everything from a 450-square-foot boutique to a multi-service wellness destination. Each will be profiled in an upcoming issue of the magazine.
Why this is actually a big deal
The stores on this list aren't competing on the same terms. The Quirky Pet in Montpelier added a catnip dispensary, a front-yard catio, and an on-site dog park after a flood destroyed the original store. South Bark pioneered self-service dog washes and invented the Blueberry Facial. One winner grew from a food truck and online store into a pet cafe and boutique in Long Branch, NJ. Another runs a learning center and lifestyle brand for groomers. A third offers a vast array of raw foods, unique events, and community givebacks.
What ties them together: each one built something specific to their market that goes beyond stocking the right SKUs.
What this means for the shelf
For the store owner: Look at where the winners put their capital. The Quirky Pet added a catnip dispensary, catio, and dog park. South Bark built self-service dog washes. One winner opened a pet cafe. Another created a zen center for dogs with training. These aren't product assortment moves, they're investments that turn a transaction into a visit. The Quirky Pet also added employee ownership and Kibble Cab delivery as it evolved.
For the buyer: The winners on this list made space for grooming, training centers, raw food education, and live animal sections. One store focuses on the whole pet and draws customers from nearby towns and states, according to the source. If your layout still prioritizes aisle efficiency over zones where customers can linger and learn, study what these stores built instead.
For the brand/DTC operator: The stores winning this recognition emphasize live animals, education, experience, and deep commitment to customers and their pets, according to the profiles. If your pitch to independents still leads with margin points and case pack size, you're solving for a different kind of store than the ones on this list.
How we're thinking about it
The through-line across all nine winners is specificity. One store focuses on the whole pet. Another created a zen center for dogs with an enlightened approach to training. A third runs a learning center and lifestyle brand for groomers. A fourth offers a vast array of raw foods and unique community events. None of them are trying to be everything to everyone, they picked a lane, went deep, and made it work for their market.
The stores that win aren't competing on product assortment anymore. They're competing on reasons to show up.
That's the real shift. These stores built something rooted in their community, whether it's The Quirky Pet's on-site dog park and heartfelt attention to detail, or South Bark's legacy as one of the first self-service dog washes in the country, or the pet cafe that started as a food truck.
The other pattern: evolution. Multiple winners explicitly called out growth through iteration. One store grew from 1,200 square feet to 3,000 and posted consecutive years of growth. Another added employee ownership and Kibble Cab delivery. The Quirky Pet rebuilt after a flood and came back different. Evolution shows up across the list.
If this is the kind of operator-level read you want every week, subscribe to PetRetailNews.
What to do about it
-
If you're running a single-location store under 2,000 square feet... pick one experiential element you can add in the next 90 days. A self-wash station. A weekly trainer night. A rescue adoption corner. The winners on this list built these one at a time.
-
If you're already offering services... look at your layout. Are customers walking straight to checkout, or are you creating zones where they stop, browse, and ask questions? The stores on this list made space for grooming bars, training areas, and education, that's a merchandising decision, not a construction project.
-
If you're a buyer or category manager... audit your assortment for products that support the services you offer. Are you stocking the treats that support a training class? The grooming tools that complement a self-wash? The raw food selection that one winner built a reputation on? The winners didn't just add services, they built product categories around them.
-
If you run a store in a competitive market... find the one thing only you can do because of your location, your relationships, or your expertise. The winners on this list built moats through vet partnerships, rescue integrations, and community ties, like the store that offers community givebacks, or the one that created a learning center for groomers.
-
If you're a brand trying to win independent distribution... study the stores on this list and ask: does our product help them deliver on what they're known for? If the answer is just "it's a good SKU," you're pitching the wrong angle.
The Bottom Line
The stores winning industry recognition in 2025 built something specific to their market, a catnip dispensary, a dog park, a pet cafe, a groomer learning center, and evolved as they grew.