You're Sitting Across From a Rep With a Price Sheet. That's No Longer the Negotiation.

You're sitting across from a supplier rep. They slide over a price sheet. You used to negotiate that number, sign the PO, and move on. Now you're asking about their innovation roadmap, their lead times during a freight spike, whether they'll fund an endcap, and what their packaging certifications actually say.

The negotiation just grew four more variables

Price remains on the table, but it's no longer the only deciding factor, according to multiple European retailers and a North American manufacturer interviewed by Global Pet Industry. Commercial discussions now extend to innovation cadence, supply reliability, marketing support, and sustainability credentials.

France's Federation of Commerce and Distribution teamed up earlier this year with five major retailers, including Carrefour, to release data on price negotiations. According to the FCD and those companies, "without commercial negotiation from retailers, a basket of 12 products would cost 37% more" than the price paid by consumers in store. The analysis aims to shift criticism regarding price hikes away from retailers and onto suppliers.

But setting blame aside, the structure of the negotiation itself has changed. Ron van Veldhoven, CEO of Dutch pet services company Pet Service Holding, told Global Pet Industry that while pricing remains important, "we increasingly focus on the total value a supplier brings. Reliable supply, product quality, innovation, inventory availability and marketing support have become just as important as the purchase price."

Pamela Nelimarkka, Chief Operating Officer at Musti Group, said cost transparency is the biggest shift. "Now negotiations start from a much more detailed breakdown of input costs - raw materials, freight, energy, packaging - and we expect suppliers to justify each line rather than bundle everything into a single percentage increase," she told Global Pet Industry.

What actually sits on the table now

Current discussions typically include delivery reliability, lead times, payment terms, exclusivity, digital content, stock availability, and sustainability, van Veldhoven said. "We also look at how suppliers can support online growth through high-quality product information and consumer marketing."

Musti Group said it has become firmer on marketing cooperation, "requiring it whenever we launch a new brand or give a supplier wide distribution, since that level of commitment on our side needs matching investment from theirs," Nelimarkka said. There's also more emphasis on sustainability documentation during the evaluation process, especially regarding packaging materials, sourcing certifications, and emissions data.

Alexander Amicucci, founder and CEO of Italian specialty retailer Zoopark, told Global Pet Industry that before agreeing to any price increase, "we expect it to be supported by clear and objective reasons, such as genuine increases in raw material, production or logistics costs." Whenever possible, Zoopark also negotiates territorial exclusivity, dedicated commercial conditions, and marketing or launch support for brands entering the retail network.

If your week runs on calls like this one, subscribe to PetRetailNews.

A report from consultancy firm McKinsey describes this movement as a transformation of supplier relationships "from trade negotiations to integrated commercial partnerships." From a survey of 43 North American grocers, the firm found that 64% of them expect trade, retail media, and business planning to be mostly integrated in the next two years, something which will factor into negotiations.

"Brands that continuously innovate and support their retail partners are much more likely to receive additional investment. Conversely, brands with declining demand, inconsistent supply or limited differentiation become candidates for rationalization."

Innovation became a negotiating lever, not a nice-to-have

Product innovation matters, with genuinely differentiated products or exclusive ranges often giving suppliers more room in negotiations, Musti Group said. The same holds true for Pet Service Holding. "Brands that continuously innovate and support their retail partners are much more likely to receive additional investment. Conversely, brands with declining demand, inconsistent supply or limited differentiation become candidates for rationalization," van Veldhoven said.

Adam DeJulius, CEO and President of manufacturer Oma's Pride, said his negotiations are subject to different dynamics because the company distributes only to neighborhood pet outlets. "The discussion is less about national scale and more about whether we are the right fit for a retailer's customers and limited freezer space. That space has become more valuable," he told Global Pet Industry.

From a manufacturer perspective, retail and distribution consolidation has made access more difficult for emerging brands, DeJulius pointed out. "Distributors want established demand, reliable velocity and a credible growth plan."

Oma's Pride seeks retail partners willing to build a strategy together. "We expect transparency, reliability and a partnership mindset. Successful suppliers understand our customers, invest in innovation and work together with us to create sustainable growth," DeJulius said. The same applies to distribution partners, the best distributors provide data, identify the right accounts, offer market feedback, and help improve velocity.

The structural pressure making this permanent

Germany's Monopolies Commission, an independent advisory body, highlighted the growing influence of retailers in commercial negotiations. In a November 2025 report on competition in the food supply chain, it noted that four retail groups control around 85% of the country's food retail market, strengthening their bargaining position with manufacturers.

Retailers are also consolidating their bargaining power across borders. Last year, Carrefour, France's Coopérative U, and Germany's RTG International established Concordis, a European buying alliance representing more than €125 billion ($140.4 billion) in combined turnover. Operational for the 2026 negotiation round, the alliance pools purchasing negotiations with major multinational branded-goods suppliers, aiming to improve commercial conditions and strengthen competitiveness.

What changes when you walk back to your desk

For the buyer: Your leverage just expanded from one variable to five. You can now trade a point of margin for guaranteed new SKUs every quarter, co-op funds for an endcap program, or supply priority during the next freight spike. The suppliers who show up with only a cost story lose to competitors offering a full commercial package. Before your next line review, write down what you actually need beyond price, innovation cadence, marketing dollars, lead-time guarantees, and negotiate those explicitly.

For the brand operator: If you're pitching independents or regional chains and your deck is three slides of wholesale cost and margin, you're already behind. Build a commercial package that includes your innovation roadmap, your supply reliability during disruptions, what marketing support you'll commit to (digital assets, co-op funds, launch kits), and your sustainability credentials with actual documentation. The buyer sitting across from you is being asked to justify shelf space on all five fronts, so give them all five answers.

For the store owner: If your buyers are still negotiating on price alone, you're leaving margin and traffic on the table. The suppliers winning shelf space now bundle innovation, marketing dollars, and supply certainty into the deal. Train your buyers to ask for the full package, and track whether the brands you stock are actually delivering on the non-price commitments they made. A supplier who promised quarterly innovation and hasn't shipped a new SKU in nine months just told you where their priorities sit.

The negotiation didn't get easier. It got wider. The rep who walks in ready to talk about all five variables is the one who walks out with the PO.

← Back to the Newsdesk